From Winey Opines, the newsletter. Every answer below is quoted from a
published post, and every post is linked.
Winey Opines No. 1
Is blouge a real wine style?
It’s a real practice with a new name – red and white grapes fermented or blended together. No legal definition, no single style.
Is blouge just rosé?
No. Rosé is usually red grapes only, with brief skin contact. Blouge involves white grapes too, and often tastes more like a light red than a pink.
Should I age it?
No. Drink it cold, drink it this year.
Read it in full: Blouge: hype or substance?
Winey Opines No. 2
Is 2026 the earliest harvest ever in Burgundy?
For actual picking, it beat 2020 by one day. The 1556 figure is a record for the official permission date, not for picking.
Is 2026 the earliest ever in Bordeaux?
No. The Bordeaux wine council says 1893 was earlier.
Does an early, hot harvest mean bad wine?
It means uneven wine – riper, softer, stronger and more variable between producers. Some of it will be very good.
Should I buy 2026 futures?
Not on a headline. Wait for the 8 September estimate, then wait for names.
Read it in full: France picked in August. Here’s what that means.
Winey Opines No. 3
Can the alcohol on the label be wrong?
Legally, yes: up to 1.5 points either way in the US for wines at or under 14 percent, one point above that, half a point in the EU and 0.8 for its sparkling, fortified and long-aged bottles.
Does “2022” mean all the wine is from 2022?
No. At least 95 percent for an American appellation, 85 for a state or country, 85 in the EU.
Does “Cabernet Sauvignon” mean it’s all Cabernet?
At least 75 percent in the US, 85 in the EU.
Does “reserve” mean anything?
Not in the United States. “Estate bottled” does.
Read it in full: The label says 13.5%. The wine can be 15%.
Winey Opines No. 4
Is there really a wine glut?
Yes. Consumption is at its lowest since 1957 by the OIV’s count, vineyards are being pulled out, and Italy, Australia and California are holding far more wine than they can sell.
Are wines cheaper because of it?
Some. Bulk-sourced wines, store brands and anonymous bottlings from big regions, yes. Famous names, no. European imports in the US carry a 15 percent tariff that eats much of the discount.
What should I buy?
Wines from 2022 to 2024 that shops are closing out, sold on region and grape rather than a name, by the case when the value is there.
Should I buy to invest?
No.
Read it in full: A once-in-a-lifetime buyer's market, with conditions.
Winey Opines No. 5
How big is France’s 2026 harvest?
The first official estimate is 33.9 million hectolitres, 6 percent below 2025 and 17 percent below the five-year average, provisional.
Is Champagne really down by half?
The ministry says 49 percent below last year. The houses hold reserve wine for exactly this; expect thinner reserves later, not empty shelves now.
Will French wine get more expensive?
The famous names will use the year as a reason. The south, which grew, has no reason at all.
Is a tiny harvest a great vintage?
Sometimes. Concentration and cooking come from the same heat. Read it bottle by bottle when it lands.
Read it in full: France's number landed. Here's what it means for your next bottle.
Winey Opines No. 6
Is an 80-cent happy hour ever worth it?
As a discount, no. As a glass, only if the wine was fairly priced to begin with, and a nine-dollar glass of a nine-dollar bottle was not.
Bottle or glass?
Two glasses each, bottle. One glass each, glass, unless the bottle divided by five is close to the glass price, in which case bottle anyway.
What should a glass cost relative to the bottle?
One fifth, plus a little for the pour. More than a quarter of the bottle price is a markup for indecision.
Why hasn’t the glut made restaurant wine cheaper?
Because restaurants buy brands through distributors at contract prices, and price the glass against the cocktails, not against what the grapes cost.
What is the safest good-value pour at a chain?
Sparkling from Spain or Italy, or a Rhône or Beaujolais red. Cheap to buy, hard to ruin.
Is corkage worth it?
Above about sixty dollars on the list, usually yes.
Read it in full: The 80-cent happy hour.
Winey Opines No. 7
Does “Red Blend” mean the wine is cheap or bad?
No. It means no grape reaches 75 percent. Some of the best bottles in California are Red Blends by law.
Why doesn’t the winery just print the grapes?
Federal label approval per vintage, a blend that changes every year, and a brand built on the name rather than the recipe. Sometimes because the recipe is nothing to brag about.
What’s the fastest tell on a Red Blend?
The back label: “produced and bottled by” versus “cellared” or “vinted by.”
Does the appellation matter more than the grapes?
On a blend, usually yes. A small named place is an address; “California” is a shrug.
Can a Red Blend be sweet without saying so?
Yes. Residual sugar isn’t required on the label.
Read it in full: Red Blend: what the label is allowed to hide.
Winey Opines No. 8
Is California wine cheaper now?
At the bottom, yes: big-brand and store-label bottles are better wine for the same money. Famous names haven’t moved.
Which California wines are the best value right now?
Named-region reds and Pinot Noir at fifteen to twenty-five dollars, old-vine Lodi Zinfandel and California sparkling under twenty.
Why isn’t Napa cheaper if there’s a glut?
The surplus is in grapes grown by the ton for brands. Napa’s grapes and Napa’s customers are a separate market that hasn’t softened.
Will prices drop further?
Growers expect removals to continue into next year, so the bottom of the shelf stays soft; the top stays where it is.
Read it in full: California is pulling out a quarter of its vines. Your shelf noticed before you did.
Winey Opines No. 9
How does Winey price a wine without tasting it?
From the producer, the place, the grape and the year on the label, against what that combination has been worth, the way an appraiser prices a painting from the signature and the provenance.
Can Winey tell if a bottle is corked or damaged?
No. Nothing on a label can. If it smells of wet cardboard, take it back.
What does “I don’t know this one” mean?
That Winey has no reliable read on the producer or the wine and won’t invent a number. It’s a feature.
Is Winey paid by wineries or shops?
No. Nobody pays Winey to like the wine.
Read it in full: What I can't taste, and why that's the point.
Winey Opines No. 10
How long does wine keep after buying it?
Most wine is made to drink now and holds for two or three years. Only wines built to age, serious reds, high-acid whites, sparkling and sweet wines, need a window at all.
How accurate are drink windows?
Roughly, plus or minus a couple of years on a ten-year window, and worse if the bottle was stored badly.
Should I open wine early or late in its window?
Early if you have several bottles, so the first teaches you about the rest. Early half if you have one.
Does a screwcap change the drink window?
Yes. It ages the wine slower and more evenly, so lean toward the later end of any range.
Read it in full: A drink window is a guess. Here's how I make mine.
Winey Opines No. 11
Should I buy wine from a winery in bankruptcy?
Yes, if the price is right. The bottle is unchanged. Pay at pickup or per shipment and never in advance.
Is Gundlach Bundschu closing?
No sign of it. The winery and tasting room are operating through the process. The family may end up a minority owner of its own name.
Will Signorello be sold?
That is the plan. The bankruptcy exists to sell the estate as a running business rather than let the lender auction the pieces.
Will Napa prices fall?
Tasting fees, yes. Bottle prices at the top end, mostly not. The correction is concentrated under $12 a bottle, where the glut lives. Above $50 the lists have barely moved.
Is the wine industry collapsing?
No. It shrank 2 percent last year. What is collapsing is the balance sheet of the wineries that borrowed for a 2019 that never came back.
Who is next?
I do not know, and I will not guess names. The shape is what I can give you: borrowed between 2019 and 2022 for hospitality or an acquisition, depends on the tasting room for most of its revenue, one lender, no wholesale cushion. There are hundreds of those.
Does any of this make the wine better or worse?
Neither. Read the bottle, not the balance sheet.
Read it in full: Why California wineries are going bankrupt now.